Shame
A few days ago I had an important conference call and in the days before the call, I was feeling anxious and distressed anticipating the call but unclear about why. I went for a walk the day of the call, and during the walk I realized I was feeling ashamed. I had the belief that the other four folks on the call were expecting me to be clear and ready to decide on something that was important to all five of us.
Instead, I was not clear at all about the decision.
In my culture of origin, confusion was not acceptable; it would show weakness. The prevailing norm was that you had to be clear, concise, on point, and tracking, and if you weren’t then you were “lesser than,” you were weak. Of course it was dangerous to be weak in every way possible—physically, psychologically, and emotionally.
Thus, as I unpacked all of this in anticipation of the conference call, I realized that I was ashamed that I was “weak” in not being clear about what I wanted to do, and I was ashamed that I was ashamed.
Up until about six months ago, I had not ever, to my memory, acknowledged that I felt ashamed. In my family of origin, you did not acknowledge that feeling—it was shameful to feel ashamed. This came to my awareness in reading a number of things, including Brene Brown’s book, The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You’re Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are. I was talking about it in workshops a lot and realized that instead of acknowledging shame, I had always said I was embarrassed. Most of my life I had conflated shame and embarrassment.
As I walked, then, I imagined a whole dialogue of letting the others on the conference call in on my realization during my check in. Thinking through the script of that dialogue brought me a lot of relief, and then I realized I was now anxious about revealing this to people. After all, everything I was planning to reveal was taboo—being confused (and therefore “weak”) and being ashamed.
Nonetheless, after everyone else checked in, I told them my story.
It was scary to do so—my heart rate was up and my palms were clammy as I related the above to them. I then asked for feedback, and I was very moved by their feedback and really liked how the conversation went after that. I was so relieved to have shared what I said, especially because the contrast between how I had felt before and after was clear.
I was no longer affected by this huge issue of my lack of clarity about the decision; it was like this big burden was relieved from me. All of my tormented thinking about my confusion was removed and I could just be in the meeting and say, “I’m not clear and I would like to get clarity.” I could break it down into specific things I was not clear about and talk them through, getting collaboration from people on the call. We ended up making a decision that all five of us seemed pleased with.
As I reflected on this later, it made me think about how hiding our shame—being ashamed of being ashamed—is exactly what gives it more power. Revealing it and including others in our experience dissipates that power; the shame fades under the light of revelation. This is exactly the opposite of what the shame is telling us to do. Our shame instructs us to hide it, both whatever we are ashamed of and the fact that we are ashamed, and when we listen to it, we stay imprisoned under it. As soon as I revealed it, difficult though that was, all the anxiety and stress I had experienced faded away.
Liberation lies just beyond revealing the truth of our experience.
I encourage you to inquire into those areas where you feel shame, and see what you find. How, in a safe way, might you share these feelings with someone close to you, just as an experiment to see what happens as a result?
Post by Ike Lasater with Julie Stiles
Posted: June 16th, 2011 under Thinking Shifts.
Tags: clarity, liberation, shame
Comments
Comment from Rachel
Time June 22, 2011 at 5:54 pm
Thank you so much for sharing about your experience of meta-shame (feeling ashamed of feeling ashamed). I am grateful for the reassurance that i am not the only one to experience this über-emotion. And i am grateful for the reminder to speak my truth about that the meta-shame – and how that deflates the emotion. This reminder gave me the courage to reach out this morning. I am awed at how quickly that diffused the shame. My guess is that talking about shame meets my need for belonging!
Comment from Sofie Bakker
Time June 21, 2011 at 10:31 am
I would like to share how for me the experience of shame is part of integrating nvc into my life.
I too read the book of Brené Brown and so became aware of when I am experiencing shame.
I spent a coffeevisit with an nvc friend and his new girlfriend, and somehow was not able to respond empathically, I kept talking about myself. All of a sudden they left and I felt a lot of shame, thinking what they would be thinking about me now. Like I lead a practice group but am not albe to listen in real life.
Also I end up in shame sometimes trying to parent nvc in a power-over environment. I wish to stay in request consiousness when at the same time the other parents are making their child behave, say thank you for instance. At times when my child refuses to say thank you or to say goodbye, it happens there is this shameful feeling in me. Fearing how I am being perceived as a mother.
Shame is so painful for me because it touches my need for belonging and my need for being seen as I am.